I'll keep this brief, as I'm hopefully doing a proper review of this for my site in the next week or so, and I doubt anyone actually reads everyone else's track-by-tracks anyway, but :
The utterly awesome : Straight Flush (one of my favourite Brummel songs of all time, I think), Motorology (even my non-Ozma-liking girlfriend likes this), No-One Needs To Know, Incarnation Blues, Heartache vs Heartache
The pretty darned good : I Wonder, Underneath My Tree, Barriers, the first thirty seconds or so of Lunchbreak when it sounds like a fun rock 'n' roll musical pastiche
The eh, not so much : Eponine, Fight The Darkness
The ew, no : the rest of Lunchbreak
So all in all, it's a success, and contains some of the best material they've ever recorded. But bits of it still sound a bit too high-schooley. Somewhere between three and four stars for me, I think.